Skip to main content
When Applications Go Wrong



Elaborating further from this post, let's take a look at an incorrectly filed application, which will show why correct application preparations are so advantageous to applicants.


On January 17th, The TNG Group submitted an application for La Bella Belly Maternity. You can view the record here.

Mistake #1

Comprehensive Research Appears to Have Been Skipped

A quick search for La Bella for clothing wielded no results - that's good. However, a quick search for Bella for clothing did show two registered marks, both Bella & both owned by Color Image Apparel, Inc. The records can be viewed here and here.

Now La Bella Belly Maternity and the logo may be distinctive enough to bypass a refusal from the USPTO. Only time will tell...

Mistake #2

Goods Description

The application is filed for International Class (IC thereafter) 25, namely, "Maternity Apparel, Accessories and Spa Services" & there are a couple of mistakes going on here:

a) There are 2, if not 3, different classes listed here.

Clothing or apparel is in IC 25, so that's correct.

The word accessories is vague & the applicant could mean anything from belts or scarves(IC 25) to purses or diaper bags(IC 18) to, given the customer, baby bottles or pacifiers (IC 10).

Spa services could either be in IC 43 (Spa services, namely, providing temporary accommodations and meals to clients of a health or beauty spa) OR in IC 44 (Day spa services, namely, nail care, manicures, pedicures and nail enhancements -- to name one).

La Bella Belly has only paid for 1 classification, which means if they want to pursue those other classes, an additional $325 per class must be paid to the USPTO.

b) The actual descriptions are incorrect:

"Maternity apparel" should be written as, for example, "maternity clothing, namely, shirts, shorts, pants, [and on & on with ALL of the items within the line]..."

The USPTO does not like words like accessories, products, etc. The applicant will have to be specific.

Since spa services can fit into 2 different classes (see above), further information will be needed.

Mistake #3

Description of Mark

While the description on the application ("The mark consists of La Bella Belly is green. Maternity is also green. Logo (pregnant lady) is also green. Green used for all words and Logo is R 138 Hue 90 G 219 Sat 127 B 158 Lum 168") makes sense to the applicant, it's not what the USPTO is looking for for that section.

A more appropriate description would be: "Stylized lettering of La Bella Belly Maternity displayed in green and appearing to the left of a shadow/silhouette of a pregnant woman, which is also displayed in green."

That description provides a visual image of what the mark looks like, which is what the USPTO requires.

Mistake #4

The specimen provided by the applicant is appropriate for the spa services but not for the other classifications, which means if the clothing & whatever the accessories end up being are pursued, new specimens will have to be submitted.

Now the last 3 mistakes can easily be corrected & it's my guess that the USPTO will be sending out an office action to the applicant in the next coming months requesting these changes. What this means is adding on even more time to the year it already takes the USPTO to grant registration. The similar marks, for clothing, may present more of a hiccup to the applicant.

I hope this post & Friday's post have really shown how important comprehensive research & correct application preparation is to each & every applicant. Given that about 1000 applications are filed every day, please be sure to have your work done right the first time.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Trademark 101: State Trademark or Federal Trademark?

Now that you know what a trademark is, what a trademark isn’t, and that you should get a trademark, let’s explore if a State trademark or Federal trademark is most appropriate for your needs.
For the USA, trademarks can be obtained either at the State level or the Federal level. So, which do you need? I’ll explain both and that’ll give you a clearer picture as where to go from here.
First and foremost, a State trademark gives you trademark protection for that specific state whereas a Federal trademark gives you trademark protection nationwide. Simple enough, yes? But, which is the right trademark for your needs?
1)Are you actively in business? 2)Are you only doing business in one city or county or just statewide?
If you answered yes to both, then exploring a State trademark is your next step. Here are some advantages to a State trademark:
·The right to expand statewide. The name will be waiting for you in other metros. ·If another mark is infringing upon yours within the state, you’ll have a…

Trademark 101: Should You Trademark?

Now that we know what a trademark is and is not, let’s dive into the next logical question: should you trademark?
The easiest way to answer this question is to look at your business and your plans for it.
-Is the name, logo, or slogan an integral part of your business? -Are you doing business on a statewide or nationwide or international level? If you’re only doing business citywide or countywide, do you see potential for geographical growth? -Would another business in your industry using the same or similar name hurt your business? In other words, is it possible you’d lose customers if someone had the same or similar name in your industry?
If you answered yes to any of the above then exploring a trademark is the way to go.
Here’s what a US Federal trademark gives you:
·A legal presumption of your ownership of the mark and your exclusive right to use the mark nationwide on or in connection with the goods/services listed in the registration (whereas a state registration only provides rights…

Trademark 101: What Isn’t a Trademark?

Yesterday’s post was all about what a trademark is so today we’re going to talk about what a trademark is not. Knowing both sides of that coin will give you a clear idea if a trademark is right for you or not.
Let’s use yesterday’s examples as a jumping off point:
·PEACE is the name of your new clothing line and your logo is the peace sign. Both of these things appear on the tags that are attached to the clothing items. You have a variety of designs and sayings that appear on the front of your clothing items, e.g. the front of a t-shirt.
·LOVE is the name of your daycare services. Your slogan, Love blooms here, appears on the web site, the brochures for new parents, the signage inside & outside of the facility. There are also multiple heart designs, created by you, used in your advertisements.
·HAPPINESS is the name you use for your invention, a new kind of food processor. You have stacks & stacks of technical documents explaining how your invention works and every page has the n…